Skip to content

McDow International Enterprises

  • McDow International Enterprises
  • My History
    • Welcome
    • Family History
  • Photo History
    • In The Community
    • Stephen’s Martha’s Vineyard
  • Home
Stephen's Articles

Q&A: Is There Tension Between Marketing & Development? Exponential Success Depends On Synergy!

iStock_000005714054XSmallThe tension between marketing/communications and those that produce revenue, membership/development, is often challenging within an organization. Equally challenging, are leaders who do not see a value in establishing and maintaining synergy between marketing/communications and membership/development. Organizations lacking that synergy often grapple with having to solve disjointed departmental communications and operations, inconsistent brand messaging, poor text heavy marketing collateral, and ineffective call-to-action campaigns that bore the community of existing and potential stakeholders. Recently, a well-educated Ivy League graduate and senior leader at a Boston, Massachusetts area non-profit asked me a question while addressing the details of my professional background:

  • How do you make the leap from marketing/communications to membership?
  • How do those two experiences even relate?

I responded:

Any membership outreach and retention effort is only as good as its ability to communicate a core mission in a cohesive and consistent manner. You obtain that cohesiveness and consistency through building visually attractive and targeted branding; a clean “hook” or message; a personal customer focus and touch; and efficient internal processes. I believe those basic principles (simplified) will place any organization in a better position to be successful in an already saturated world of associations and non-profits. 

Even after the conversation was over, I was not sure what to think about the question. I had to seek the counsel of more senior professionals to get different perspectives. I asked the members of the Linked-in group, Non Profit Message – Communications & Marketing to:

Tell me why there is a disconnect, in non-profits, between marketing/communications and membership?CT CT-BIZ-WORK-ADVICE_CTMAIN 0521 SR

The first response came from Mr. Ken Handel, a senior communications and public relations professional with over 20 years of experience working for organizations such as Lehman College, the New School University, and The Jewish Museum.  Mr. Handel said:

It depends on the particular institution – specifically the mid-level managers. In one professional experience I worked as a director of publications and the promotional writer. One of my responsibilities was to collaborate with the director of membership. When that department needed a new basic brochure, I provided them with copy. There, the relationship between marketing/communications and membership worked well.

Yet, in colleges I have experienced an almost total disconnect between development and marketing/communications. Sometimes there are temporary dedicated marketing/communication professionals attached to development. However, that only seems to exist for large projects like a view-book or annual report. Other than that, the two departments seem to rarely collaborate. At one university, I convened a meeting of mid-level administrators from the various academic divisions to regularly assess whether marketing/communications were functioning as expected for everyone.

iStock_000010106679What Mr. Handel expressed regarding the departmental disconnect is exactly what I experienced as a professional, working in the membership department for a Washington, DC based association. I noticed that my colleagues were producing membership outreach materials without consulting the marketing department. These materials, though marginally acceptable, didn’t follow the organizations basic rules of branding. From a marketing perspective, I offered to provide some input; however, at that time, I was the most junior member of the team and those with more tenure made sure to tell me that my input was not welcome and that membership had something to prove.

Internal department competition is good; however, it can disrupt the ability to accomplish challenging goals with a high quality product if ego’s get in the way. To that end, the second response came from Mr. Michael McWilliams, Executive Director of Rapporteur, an issue advocacy consulting organization that focuses on social change and environmental action.

Mr. McWilliams has over 30 years experience with organizations such as Prudential, The Foxboro Company, MassINC, and the Stockholm International Water Institute. He says:

I think that there’s a natural tension between the revenue-generating and communication/outreach areas of mostargument_000018978579_620x350 organizations. This can actually be a positive thing if the tension produces good dialog and new ideas. Unfortunately, it all-to-often devolves into internal competition, especially in times like these when many organizations are in survival mode. Great organizations work hard at developing an esprit-de-corps that creates an environment where the different groups get on the same page and work well together. These generally seem to be the ones who focus on the big picture and simply resolve the less important things that make it difficult to work together. Less effective organizations tend to emphasize internal process and operations. The fund-raising and membership side tends to complain when “it doesn’t get its way” and the communications/outreach side just hunkers down and does what it must to get through the day. I’ve seen an example up close and it wasn’t pretty. Fortunately, the board took action and the organization seems on the right track now. It’s common in every sector, not just nonprofits.

Even with the natural tension and competition between departments there is hope for synergy. I saw it work well and efficiently at the Orange County Medical Association, where I managed membership and communications. Based on budget and necessity the two departments were combined. However, even without the operational needs, it made sense from a strategy perspective to have the departments together. Ms. Robbie Searcy, a communications professional with well over 20 years of experience with organizations such as the Lower Colorado River Authority, Capital Area Food Bank in Texas and WXGR 101.5 FM radio in New Hampshire said:

I have seen the two work in collaboration very effectively. In one case, the marketing vice president, who oversaw the directors of development and communications, was a passionate visionary (and has since become the CEO of another nonprofit). It’s important that all contributors, storytellers and service providers alike, understand how they can complement each other’s success by sharing ideas and resources. A little friendly competition to bring in good ideas and support can be healthy for the organization. But a shared focus on mission, rather than ego and career survival, is the keys to exponential success.

iStock_000010106679The proof is in the experiences of these senior level marketing/communications professionals. I couldn’t agree with Ken, Michael, and Robbie more.

The tension between the two departments is both natural and necessary.

However, the need to understand the interwoven connections between marketing/communications and membership/development is key in establishing and maintaining relevancy as an organization. The quality of these departments synergy will determine your current and future stakeholders financial support.

Advertisement

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Print
  • Pocket

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

April 13, 2013April 19, 2019 McDow International E/Stephen McDow II2012 boston marathon, Abortion Rights, ACLU, advocacy, advocacy definition, advocacy groups, advocate, advocate definition, advocate health, advocating, african american art, african american artists, against abortion, agriculture, aloe vera juice, amazon, american public education, anti abortion, aol news, appeal democrat, appropriations, arena football, arizona senators, arkansas democrat gazette, art in america, auction, baa, balloon juice, Barack Obama, barack obama biography, barackobama.com, barak obama, beach resorts, benefits of juicing, bill, bill clinton speech, bioware social network, black and white, black art, black art pictures, black artists, black artwork, black death, black house white market, black market white house, blade and soul, boehner, book stores, bookstore, Boston, boston marathon, boston marathon 2012, boston marathon 2012 date, boston marathon 2012 results, boston marathon 2013, boston marathon qualifying time, boston marathon qualifying times, boston marathon results, boston marathon route, boston t, brady udall, breville juicer, business, business partnership, business partnership agreement, california state assembly, canon digital learning center, cardinal health, casablanca, CBS 2, cellco partnership, census, cgi, child advocacy, child chronic illnesses, child sex, cindy, cindy mccain, city of laguna beach, Civil Rights Act, climate, clinton, cloud services, cnn politics, college, compass pa, Congress, congress plaza hotel, congress theater, Consulting, contact, continental congress, craigslist, crp, crr, current-events, cursive alphabet, daily paul, dailypaul, dark souls, day, ddc advocacy, death, death cab for cutie, death clock, death note, death of a salesman, death penalty, death quotes, death valley, define advocacy, define advocate, define prolific, definition of advocate, Dell's Chief Procurement Officer, Democrat, democrat and chronicle, democratic, democratic donkey, democratic national committee, democratic national convention, democratic national convention 2012, democratic party, democratic party platform, democratic underground, Democrats, department of public welfare, die, digital learning center, digital media and learning, digital media learning, diocese of cleveland, dnc, dpw, draw the line, drug testing, drug testing for welfare, dying, ebay, edu, Education, education publications, education reform, edwin mccain, elementary, Elementary and Secondary Education Act, ema, face, face book, facebok, facebook, facebook login, facebook.com, faces of death, famous african american women, famous black women, fb, federal poverty level, First Amendment, five finger death punch, foundation, free appropriate public education, gay social network, general partnership, georgia world congress center, global issues, global partners, government assistance, grass roots, grass roots band, grassroots, grassroots california, grassroots campaign, grassroots campaigns, grassroots definition, grassroots festival, grassroots hats, grassroots lobbying, grassroots marketing, grassroots motorsports, group health, handwriting, handwriting worksheets, harvard, harvard business review, harvard business school, harvard college, harvard crimson, harvard extension school, harvard pilgrim, harvard school of education, harvard university, Health, health advocate, health articles, Health care, health partners, hillary clinton, hive, hobby lobby, hobby lobby ad, hobby lobby coupon, hobby lobby coupons, hobby lobby hours, hobby lobby locations, hobby lobby weekly ad, hobby lobby.com, hot line, hotel laguna, hotline, house, House of Representatives, http, huff, huff post, huffington, Huffington Post, huffington post chicago, huffington post crime, huffington post los angeles, huffington post news, huffington post politics, huffington post weird news, huffington post wiki, huffington post.com, huffingtonpost, huffpo, huffpost, hunger games, hunger games cast, hunger games movie, hunger games trailer, hunger games trilogy, idaho department of health and welfare, idaho digital learning academy, idaho digital learning blackboard, idaho health and welfare, impoverished, internal revenue service, Internet marketing, internet marketing -advertisement, IRS, irs forms, irs phone number, irs refund, irs where s my refund, irs.com, irs.gov, irs.gov forms, irs.gov where s my refund, jamba juice, Jewish Museum, john mccain, john mccain pow, juice, juice cleanse, juice fast, juice plus, juice recipes, juicer recipes, juicing, juicing diet, juicing for weight loss, juicing recipes, Kevin Brown, kia soul, ksu.edu, LA Times, laguna, Laguna Beach, laguna beach ca, laguna beach high school, laguna beach hotels, laguna beach restaurants, laguna beach season 1, laguna beach season 2, laguna beach weather, law, lda, leadership, learn digital photography, learn digital photography now, learning digital photography, legislative branch, Lehman College, library, library of congress, library of congress catalog, limited liability partnership, limited partnership, lobby, lobbying, lobbying definition, lobbyist, lobbyist definition, lobbyists, ludacris headphones, mapquest, marathon, marathon guide, mark udall, Marketing, Marketing and Advertising, master limited partnerships, mccain, mccain feingold, mccain foods, medical, megan mccain, meghan mccain, meghan mccain breasts, men s health, mens health, michelle obama, michelle obama speech, mike huckabee, minecraft hunger games, minecraft hunger games server, mitt romney reproductive rights, mobile world congress, molested, montage, montage laguna beach, morris udall, mtv, mtv awkward, mtv jersey shore, mtv lebanon, mtv movie awards 2012, mtv music, mtv news, mtv roadies, mtv schedule, mtv shows, mtv.com, mtv.com.lb, myspace, NAACP, nancy pelosi, naral, naral pro-choice america, national right to life, new mexico public education department, news, nm educators, nm ped, nm public education department, nmped, northeastern university, Obama, Obama 2012, obama 2016, obama approval rating, obama campaign, obama care, obama for america, obama speech, obama vs romney, ohio congressman, Orange County, orange juice, pa state, partner, partners, partners.org, partnership, partnership agreement, partnership definition, patient advocacy, patriots day, paul, pearson digital learning, ped, Pew Charitable Trust, philadelphia soul, pokemon soul silver, political, political cartoon, political cartoons, political news, political parties, political polls, political science, political wire, politics, postal news, postal service, Poverty, poverty in america, poverty level, poverty line, Pre K Now, president, President Obama, press democrat, priests for life, pro abortion, pro choice, pro choice abortion, pro life, pro life arguments, pro life vs pro choice, prolife, proliferative, proliferative diabetic retinopathy, proliferative endometrium, prolific, prolific definition, prolific usb to serial, prolific usb to serial driver, prolific usb to serial driver windows 7, public, public education, public education in america, public health education, public partnerships, public private partnerships, public relations, Public School, public schools, Publix, q&a: is there tension between marketing & development? exponential success depends on synergy! « stephen mcdow, quotes about death, race and ethnicity in the united states, real clear politics polls, related, representative, reproduction rights, reproductive, reproductive rights, reproductive rights movement, reproductive rights of women, Republican, republican party, research, right to life, romney reproductive rights, romney vs obama, ron paul, ron paul 2012, ron paul news, school, schott, science, second continental congress, self advocacy, sen. mark udall, senator john mccain, senator mark udall, senator mccain, senator tom udall, senator udall, sex education in public schools, sex hotline, Sexual abuse, sexual abuse attorney, sexual abuse counseling, sexual abuse help, sexual abuse lawyer, sexual abuse treatment, sexual assault, sexual assault definition, sexual child abuse, sexual child abuse statistics, sexual child abuse stories, sexual violence, social network, social network analysis, social network movie, social network sites, social networking, social networking sites, social networks, social security death index, social welfare, soul, soul by ludacris, soul calibur 5, soul cycle, soul eater, soul headphones, soul music, soul surfer, soul train, soulcycle, southern poverty law center, speaker, speaker boehner, spin nyc, state of new mexico, Stephen McDow, Stephen Reginald McDow, Stockholm International Water Institute, tallahassee democrat, taxes, technology, texas public education grant, tf2 lobby, the grass roots, the grassroots, the house, the huffington post, the hunger games, the hunger games movie, the hunger games trailer, the white house, thomas, tom cruise, top social networking sites, trans pacific partnership, treatment advocacy center, tv shows, udall catheter, udall colorado, udall scholarship, united health care, United States, united states united states department of agriculture, university, urban partnership bank, US Congress, us senate, vegetable juice recipes, verb definition, viacom, vitamix, vitamix juicer, Washington D.C, web, web md, webmd, webmd.com, welfare, welfare fraud, welfare pa, welfare reform, welfare statistics, what are reproductive rights, what happens when you die, what is a democrat, what is a domestic partnership, what is a lobbyist, what is advocacy, what is lobbying, what is pro choice, what is sexual assault, what is sexual child abuse, when, wheres my refund, white, White House, white house address, white house tours, whitehouse.gov, who is the speaker of the house, wikipedia, women reproductive rights, women s health, women s reproductive rights, womens reproductive rights, www.aol.com, www.compass.state.pa.us, www.facebook.com, www.go, www.house.gov, www.irs.gov, www.mtv.com, www.state.pa.us, www.yahoo, www.yahoo.com, yaho, yahoo, yahooo, Young People, Young-People Related Advocacy, youtube

Post navigation

Previous Previous post: ACT NOW: Open Table Maynard & Other Food Relief Organizations Partner With U.S. Postal Service To Stamp Out Hunger
Next Next post: Watching Life Transition From Earth To Heaven

Follow Us

  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Stephen McDow’s Tweets

  • Great day at the county council public safety hearing today discussing increased resources for LEOs in the CIT Unit… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 3 days ago
  • Great morning building new a new relationship with @wamu885 and @DCist culture & arts reporter @elliotcwilliams! Gr… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 4 days ago
  • So honored to have Dr Niculescu! Excellent!! twitter.com/bipolargirlpod… 5 days ago
  • Well @CBCPAC get ready for the frontrunner for the upcoming Republican Pres. Primary! Good luck, Mr. Douglas! You a… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 week ago
Follow @stephenmcdow

Stephen's Instagram

No Instagram images were found.

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • McDow International Enterprises
    • Join 54 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • McDow International Enterprises
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.

    %d bloggers like this: